>>We want students to be inspired by this content and then be >>>encouraged to go off and create their own musical instruments. > >I doubt it.....my students tend to be passive learners and in order to >encourage them to go off and create something I have to supply some >ideas and create an environment for them to do that. I just don't see >that a Web page that they interact with (somewhat passively) will >make them think of going off the Web and making their own instrument! > >***I disagree. A couple of weeks ago I was asked to speak to a 4th grade class >about the Common Knowledge/Carnegie Library project. These 4th graders who >will be constructing their own WebSite were extraordinarily enthusiastic. >When they saw the variety of animated gifs, they literally flipped out. I >think the majority of that class would have loved to create their own animated >gif. >How that blends in with the curriculum is the responsibility of the teacher. >The kids also loved the soundclips that I linked underneath some of my >transparent gifs. There is real potential here for constructing a site >about a >class-related topic or a site about the class itself. Well....let me try to explain more what I was thinking. I was going just from that one armonica site - you can click on the picture and then the sound comes up. I was visualizing my students (who have access to the Web) sitting there interacting with the armonica. I just don't see my students suddenly coming up with the idea (themselves) that they are going to make their own musical instruments. When I say they are passive -- often they will sit there and interact with the "thing" .... but .... they don't take it a step further without prompting. Your example is different. I agree that animated gifs make kids flip out! [Some of my html kids first period are figuring out how to make them using Gif Builder because they found some animated gifs, saved them and put them on some pages they are writing....so....when I told them they could only use original gifs...they got busy figuring it out!] So, now I am thinking....there is a difference between presenting a skill like making animated gifs, making soundclips, etc. and having the kids (and hopefully the teachers) learn these techniques....and just presenting those products as a way for kids/teachers to view a thought. I agree with you that presenting those skills and sharing those skills are very valuable in using technology as a tool to present curriculum! Suzanne