HI all, This is some group to keep up with (Coltrane's debut of "Giant Steps" comes to mind)! Before I respond to issues of professional development and educational use, some intro...I teach in the Princeton Regional Schools. I have 600 students who are kids, and 300 students who are teachers. My goal is to help all of them harness technology for lifelong learning. We have a high level of connectivity in every classroom district-wide, as well as in homework centers in the "affordable housing" sections of town, that I'd wager we'd be proud of as a result, should our efforts on this list produce this kind of access for every classroom. Now, entering a third year of work in seeing both "what this sucker will do, flat out" (meaning what are the possibilities and effects on learning) as well as "what does it take to keep this flying" (meaning what interventions are scalable and sustainable to make ever larger numbers of people confident and capable), I hope to provide some "first hand" reports to this discussion, as appropriate. This work has grown out of my prior experiences as: a Jazz Artist in Residence for the National Endowment of the Arts; an early champion of classroom Internet use; a systems analyst for a couple engineering companies, and most recently as co-author of "NetLearning: Why Teachers Use the Internet". In response to the great need educators face in learning to apply the potentials of the Internet to their work, I helped found the Online Internet Institute (OII). The OII represents a distributed educational model for ongoing collaborative professional growth created by classroom educators (see http://oii.org). Thanks to Bob Carlitz' reminder about homework, I'm off to do mine! But before doing so, a guiding principle might be: givers can be subsidized by takers. Those who contribute to the efforts needed to prepare users, verify/organize content of educator generated materials, or in other measurable ways give value to the scale up effort ought to get access from wherever they are in return. Access can be used for anything (I've had teachers in my workshops enthusiastically master html, only to produce web pages for their "side" businesses!) but when it is purposefully used to advance the opportunities for learning, it is appropriate for such access to be subsidized. Now, some responses to topics discussed thus far: 1 Who should provide professional development? On the basis of my experiences in Princeton, and working with hundreds of educators around the country, I can tell you that the challenges require more deep, sustained human involvement than most planners have the courage to quantify. OII also provides an alternative paradigm to the "let the existing educational establishment do it/let business do it" debate. Mario Zinga and Currie Morrison are right on the mark: educational value doesn't automatically follow introduction of connectivity, and both the growing body of knowledge about how people learn (which isn't necessarily how they are currently taught!) as well as the growing body of examples of successful Internet use for learning must be integrated within any "training plan" (BTW, many of us have developed an "aversion reaction" to "training" as it's proper context is for pets and circus animals) 2 Access The biggest obstacle we've faced in our national work is the great disparity between the connectivity our participants face when they return to their classrooms and homes following our onsite sessions. Providing access to classrooms without providing educators access from home simply won't work. 3. Communication vs Education Proper care is required in establishing context, but educational uses of the Internet *demand* communication, and professional uses of the Internet require skills that students ought to learn during their school years. Don't isolate these into an "either/or" situation. 4. Tracking the Keepers and the Chaff Discussion about what's relevant and what's not is highly subjective, but will ultimately and necessarily narrow the focus. Certain key ideas may not become part of the Universal Service recommendations, but ought to be captured for other efforts (like the project George Brett and Libby Black are working on for a National Coalition for Technical Training). Bob, can the archives of this and subsequent discussion be indexed for searching on phrases, and tagged for themes? Off to do my homework! Ferdi ______________________________________________________ Ferdi Serim phone: 609 921-8549 Princeton Regional Schools fax: 609 924-7347 Computer Teacher/ District Computer Coordinator Online Internet Institute, Principal Investigator http://oii.org ferdi_serim@monet.prs.k12.nj.us (school) http://prism.prs.k12.nj.us/WWW/Ferdi.html "We are more than the sum of our knowledge, we are the products of our imagination." - Ferdi